Bitcoin
BTC$30 326.91

1.12%

Ethereum
ETH$2 076.58

2.21%

Tether
USDT$0.999001

0.01%

USD Coin
USDC$1.000230

-0.02%

Binance Coin
BNB$304.44

2.05%

XRP
XRP$0.435585

2.31%

Bitcoin hardware devices need to improve to handle complex transactions


14 Sep 2020

#Bitcoin

Time for hardware wallet devices to make a difference. Jameson Lopp, co-founder and CTO of Casa, a crypto custody firm has released a test result report on Bitcoin multi-signature hardware signing performance on the Casa blog on Sep. 13. 

The result shows that hardware crypto wallet devices can handle small, simple transactions well. However, they have trouble performing once the transaction becomes complicated. Casa is said to be built upon geographically distributed multisig, dedicated hardware devices to secure keys, designed user experience, and client services.

Lopp pointed out that while the company has no control over the hardware devices, the goal is to support any device at the end of the day. Thus, he decided to conduct research and hoped to draw some conclusions and help multisig software providers better understand the limits of hardware and customize wallet software for better performance.

Casa is currently compatible with six hardware including Trezor, Ledger, Coinkite and Coldcard  The test was done on all the supported hardware devices and also BitBox.

Lopp set up the test by leveraging  Electrum's 4.0.2 appimage on Debian Linux and created a variety of P2WSH (native segwit) multisig wallets that use Bitcoin’s testnet and with the hardware devices plugged in via USB. In each wallet, there was a deposit of 100 UTXOs.

Lopp created a series of tests to determine these hardware wallet capabilities when signing multi-signature transactions of varying complexity. He repeated these tests and concluded that it’s better and more secure if hardware devices can show progress indicators for loading and signing. He added that: 

“I came to really dislike hardware devices that don't show progress indicators for loading and signing. As such, I highly prefer Coldcard and Trezor in this respect. BitBox and Ledger are anxiety-inducing because you have no idea if anything is actually happening.”

When it comes to overcoming transaction size limitation and delay of transaction processing time, Lopp suggested that hardware wallets could try to break up a send into multiple smaller transactions that are below its limits. 

When the transaction process takes too long, some devices will lock itself from inactivity. Lopp suggests that the least device manufacturers could do to avoid such inconvenience is to disable the screen lock timeout while the device is still working on the transaction. 

According to Lopp, hardware devices should also support Partially signed Bitcoin transactions (PSBT) and all possible valid multisig transactions. He added that: 

“I believe it's time for hardware manufacturers to start acting like platform providers and ensure that they are providing robust platforms that can be used to build a wide variety of solutions.”

There are two steps for hardware devices to follow when signing a Bitcoin transaction, according to Lopp:

“First, The transaction gets loaded onto the device, it parses the details and displays them on the screen for user confirmation. These details are generally the address(es) to which funds are being sent, the amount(s) being sent, and the fee being paid. Then, Upon user confirmation, the device signs each transaction input and then returns the signed transaction to the wallet software.”

Source


Related

Bitcoin’s short-term upward channel
Bitcoin’s short-term upward channel
Has Bitcoin reached the bottom?
Has Bitcoin reached the bottom?
Bitcoin's Price Plunges Below $34,000
Bitcoin's Price Plunges Below $34,000
Bitcoin stabilised but has trouble to reverse strongly
Bitcoin stabilised but has trouble to reverse strongly
Bitcoin will fall until the bulls capitulate
Bitcoin will fall until the bulls capitulate
The culmination of the battle for the trend in Bitcoin
The culmination of the battle for the trend in Bitcoin
Bitcoin undecided on a scenario for May
Bitcoin undecided on a scenario for May
Bitcoin: How the $1 million rally begins
Bitcoin: How the $1 million rally begins
Bitcoin's last hope for $38K
Bitcoin's last hope for $38K

Top Cryptocurrencies with Price Predictions

# Crypto Prediction Accuracy CVIX Price 24h 7d Market Cap 7d price change
1 Bitcoin (BTC) BTC Bitcoin predictions 65.6% 74 $30 326.91 1.12% -1.69% $577 507 167 326 BTC 7 days price change
2 Ethereum (ETH) ETH Ethereum predictions 66.4% 75 $2 076.58 2.21% -10.32% $250 891 465 462 ETH 7 days price change
3 Tether (USDT) USDT Tether predictions 96% 1 $0.999001 0.01% -0.08% $75 676 462 108 USDT 7 days price change
4 USD Coin (USDC) USDC USD Coin predictions 96% 1 $1.000230 -0.02% -0.04% $52 257 987 348 USDC 7 days price change
5 Binance Coin (BNB) BNB Binance Coin predictions 65.6% 71 $304.44 2.05% -3.10% $49 708 837 503 BNB 7 days price change
6 XRP (XRP) XRP XRP predictions 66.8% 66 $0.435585 2.31% -13.81% $21 057 536 595 XRP 7 days price change
7 Cardano (ADA) ADA Cardano predictions 68.8% 66 $0.575630 2.12% -8.16% $19 421 209 986 ADA 7 days price change
8 Solana (SOL) SOL Solana predictions 63.2% 76 $56.43 3.88% -13.30% $19 038 552 817 SOL 7 days price change
9 Binance USD (BUSD) BUSD Binance USD predictions 96% 1 $1.002005 0.22% 0.35% $18 231 060 479 BUSD 7 days price change
10 Dogecoin (DOGE) DOGE Dogecoin predictions 62.4% 73 $0.089988 2.40% -16.42% $11 938 784 018 DOGE 7 days price change
11 Polkadot (DOT) DOT Polkadot predictions 67.2% 74 $11.01 1.97% -0.91% $10 874 092 462 DOT 7 days price change
12 Avalanche (AVAX) AVAX Avalanche predictions 66.4% 75 $34.13 2.44% -22.27% $9 183 931 187 AVAX 7 days price change
13 Wrapped Bitcoin (WBTC) WBTC Wrapped Bitcoin predictions 67.2% 74 $30 349.83 1.15% -1.21% $8 599 743 334 WBTC 7 days price change
14 TRON (TRX) TRX TRON predictions 71.6% 60 $0.072402 4.12% -4.60% $7 070 299 328 TRX 7 days price change
15 SHIBA INU (SHIB) SHIB SHIBA INU predictions 64.8% 75 $0.000013 4.03% -21.64% $6 883 934 346 SHIB 7 days price change

Be the first to receive Cryptocurrency Price Predictions and Forecasts daily

Get cryptocurrency price predictions, forecasts with analysis and news right to your inbox.

© 2015-2022 Crypto-Rating.com

The usage of this website constitutes acceptance of the following legal information. Any contracts of financial instruments offered to conclude bear high risks and may result in the full loss of the deposited funds. Prior to making transactions one should get acquainted with the risks to which they relate. All the information featured on the website, including information about the cryptocurrencies and bitcoin is intended solely for informational purposes, is not a means of advertising them, and doesn't imply direct instructions for investing. Crypto Rating shall not be liable for any loss, including unlimited loss of funds, which may arise directly or indirectly from the usage of this information. The editorial staff of the website does not bear any responsibility whatsoever for the content of the comments or reviews made by the site users about cryptocurrencies. The entire responsibility for the contents rests with the authors. Reprint of the materials is available only with the permission of the editorial staff.